Thematic tech investing is exploding in popularity. Everyone wants to invest in funds that own clean energy, cybersecurity, electric vehicles, e-sports, robotics, 3D printing, and cloud computing.
But watch out, Morningstar warns: The majority of these funds do not outperform the markets, have high fees, high failure rates, and run the risk of too much concentration that could cause stocks to tank should investors suddenly flee the funds.
Thematic tech is growing fast
A bull market, and easy-to-understand themes have created an explosion of interest in thematic investing as investors have sought to put money into narrows areas of the investing universe, most of it technology themed.
In the U.S. alone, thematic funds have ballooned to more than $160 billion in assets by the end of March 2021, from about $49 billion at the end of December 2019, according to Morningstar.
But a small group of funds are gathering the lion’s share of the business. While 41 thematic funds now have assets over $1 billion, the top 10 largest account for just under half of all the assets.
Top 10 Thematic ETFs
| Name | Assets Under Management through March 31 |
|---|---|
| ARK Innovation | $22.3 b. |
| First Trust Internet | $9.8 b. |
| ARK Genomic Revolution | $9.4 b. |
| ARK Next Generation Internet | $6.9 b. |
| First Trust Cloud Computing | $5.9 b. |
| iShares Global Clean Energy | $5.5 b. |
| FlexShares Morningstar Natural Resources | $4.7 b. |
| US Global Jets | $4.0 b. |
| ARK Fintech Innovation | $4.0 b. |
| KraneShares China Internet | $3.7 b. |
While most thematic funds are tied to indexes, some are now actively managed. Cathie Wood’s ARK funds, a series of actively managed funds with a small number of concentrated bets, has attracted massive inflows.
Thematic tech: a bull market phenomenon
Not surprisingly, investors tend to rush into thematic funds, particularly thematic tech, during bull markets. Launches set records in 2016, 2018, and 2019, according to Morningstar. In 2019, a particularly strong year for stocks (the S&P 500 was up 29%), providers launched almost 40 new thematic ETF funds. In 2020, also a strong year, a record 55 new thematic strategies came to market.
Does thematic investing outperform the market?
The answer, for the most part, is no.
While thematic tech investing did well during 2020, the record is much poorer over longer periods.
Thematic investing, by its nature, is prone to investors chasing hot themes: clean energy, cloud computing, electric vehicles, battery technology, virtual reality, gaming, robotics, artificial intelligence, cybersecurity. These themes come in and out of popularity. Thematic investors are making a bet that they have picked a winning theme, but because thematic funds pick narrow, often volatile parts of the market that fall in and out of favor, they suffer from very high failure rates: nearly one-third of all thematic funds have closed in the last 10 years, and 34% have underperformed the broader equity market.
Performance of U.S. Thematic Funds (last 10 years)
| Fund Performance | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Closed | 30% |
| Outperformed | 36% |
| Underperformed | 34% |
High fees are a problem
A major contributor of thematic investing underperformance has been high fees. Thematic funds, many of which are actively managed, charge much higher fees than broad funds and even most ETFs.
Thematic Tech: Select Annual Fees
| Fund name | Fees |
|---|---|
| ARK Innovation Fund | 0.75% |
| First Trust Cloud Computing | 0.60% |
| iShares Clean Energy | 0.46% |
By comparison, the iShares S&P 500 ETF, a passively managed fund, charges an annual fee of only 0.03%.
“High fees charged by thematic funds have contributed to their relatively poor performance versus broad market indexes over longer periods,” Morningstar said.
Too much concentration?
Morningstar also noted that a small number of actively managed funds have accumulated very large positions in many small cap stocks, particularly Cathie Wood’s Ark Innovation fund.
ARK Innovation: Too much concentration?
| Name | Percentage of free float owned, March 31 |
|---|---|
| Statasys | 22.10% |
| Photo Labs | 20.10% |
| Compugen | 18.60% |
| LendingTree | 18.60% |
| Seres Therapeutics | 15.40% |
This concentrated ownership means that the stock prices may be subject to the whims of investors in the fund: “The liquidity promised by the ETF structure means investments can be pulled out on a whim,” Morningstar noted.
What’s it all mean?
Thematic investing is fun and easy to understand. I’m buying cybersecurity! I own fintech! I love clean energy!
If you like the theme but don’t have the resources to investigate individual companies, thematic investing makes sense.
But Morningstar’s report is a flag for investors: Don’t kid yourself. You have not found the Secret of Stock Market Wealth.
“Some of the same individuals will likely get burnt when the fortunes of the more popular themes inevitably wane and investors swarm for the exits,” Morningstar warns. “As timely as they may seem now, some themes will age poorly. Investors must ask themselves: Will that work-from-home ETF still be relevant in three years’ time?”
What’s the average investor to do? “Because of their narrower exposure and higher risk profile, thematic funds are best used to complement rather than replace existing core holdings,” said Kenneth Lamont, senior research analyst at Morningstar and the author of the report.